VPN No-Logs Audits Explained: Which Providers Actually Have Proof
A dated tracker of VPN no-logs audits for 10 providers: who checked, when, what was in scope and whether you can read the report. Plus how to judge any audit claim in 10 minutes.

On this page
- Who This Tracker Is For
- How We Compiled It
- The VPN No-Logs Audit Tracker
- What a No-Logs Audit Proves (and What It Doesn't)
- Four Kinds of Evidence, Ranked
- Provider Notes: The Catch With Each One
- Red Flags in a VPN's Audit Claims
- How to Check Any VPN's Audit in 10 Minutes
- Frequently Asked Questions
- The Bottom Line
A VPN no-logs audit is an independent check, usually by an accounting or security firm, of whether a provider's servers and processes match its promise not to record what you do online. Of the 10 VPNs in this tracker, six have a no-logs assessment dated within the last 13 months, two rely on server security reviews that stop short of a formal no-logs attestation and two point to reports that are 20 months to more than three years old.
That's the short version. The longer one matters, because "independently audited" on a pricing page can mean a Big Four assurance report from last month, a penetration test of one app from 2022 or a two-page letter. This tracker is part of our guide to VPNs, proxies and antidetect browsers. Every row links to the vendor's own announcement or the report itself, and we re-verify it every quarter.
In short
A no-logs audit is a snapshot. It proves how the audited servers were set up on a date, not what happens next month.
Check four things on any claim: who did it, the date it covers, what was in scope and whether you can read the report.
Proton VPN has the strongest public paper trail here: five annual audits, each report free to read.
PureVPN's newest public no-logs report covers February 2023. Mullvad and Windscribe have no formal no-logs attestation, but each has unusual real-world evidence.
Last verified: November 14, 2026, on each vendor's own pages and the published reports linked below. Next review: February 2027.
Who This Tracker Is For
It's for anyone choosing a VPN for privacy reasons who wants to see the evidence behind "no logs" before paying. It's also for writers and researchers who need a dated, sourced table to cite.
It isn't for people who need protection from a determined government investigation. No audit makes a VPN safe for that, and our honest look at whether a VPN is worth it explains what a VPN can and can't hide. It also isn't a speed or streaming comparison. We didn't test any of these apps for this page. It's a document review, and we say where we couldn't read a report ourselves.
How We Compiled It
We started with the 10 best-known consumer VPNs among the 14 services in our VPN directory. For each one we found the most recent independent check that looked at logging on the server side, then read the provider's announcement and, where it's public, the report itself. We recorded the auditor, the standard used, the date the check covers (not the date of the press release), what was in and out of scope and how a reader can get the report.
Two rules kept it honest. A vendor's own description of a report counts only as a claim, so we say "the vendor says" when we couldn't read the original. And app audits, website pentests and payment-system reviews don't count as no-logs evidence, however good they are, because they don't look at the servers your traffic passes through.
No provider paid to be listed, and none of the links below earn us anything.
The VPN No-Logs Audit Tracker
The table shows each provider's latest server-side check as of November 14, 2026. "Report public" means anyone can read the full report without buying a subscription.
VPN | Latest server-side check | Auditor and standard | Report public | What it covered |
|---|---|---|---|---|
2026 (fifth annual) | Securitum, on-site no-logs audit | Yes, free PDF | Production VPN servers, configs, change control | |
As of October 30, 2026 | KPMG Baltics, ISAE 3000 | Yes, linked from announcement | Standard, Static IP and Multiport servers, DNS | |
September 25, 2026 | Schellman Compliance | No, customer portal | Server baseline, sample server, abuse stats | |
November 10 to December 12, 2025 | Deloitte Lithuania, ISAE 3000 (Revised) | No, Nord Account | Standard, Double VPN, Onion, obfuscated | |
As of October 31, 2025 | Deloitte Romania, ISAE 3000, limited assurance | Yes, free PDF | VPN servers, change and incident processes | |
As of October 31, 2025 | Deloitte Romania, ISAE 3000, limited assurance | Yes, free PDF | VPN servers, operations, dedicated IP design | |
As of February 28, 2025 | KPMG LLP, ISAE (UK) 3000 Type 1 | Yes, after accepting terms | TrustedServer design | |
June 2024 | Packetlabs, server code review and pentest | Yes | FreshScribe server stack, about 80,000 lines | |
June 3 to 14, 2024 | Cure53, infrastructure security audit | Yes | Two staging servers built like production | |
February 16 to 22, 2023 | KPMG, technical privacy assessment letter | Yes, two-page letter | Seven servers in six countries, four claims |
Sources: Proton VPN, Surfshark, IPVanish via CyberInsider, NordVPN, CyberGhost report, PIA, ExpressVPN, Windscribe, Mullvad, PureVPN letter. All checked November 14, 2026.
What a No-Logs Audit Proves (and What It Doesn't)
An auditor gets access for a few days or weeks. They interview staff, read server configuration files, inspect a sample of servers, sometimes watch a test connection and look for any trace of it, and check how changes to the setup get approved. Then they write down what they found as of a date.
That's real evidence. It's also narrow in three ways most "best no-logs VPN" lists skip:
It's a point in time. CyberGhost's Deloitte report says outright that its procedures "do not provide any assurance" about the no-logs policy for any other period. A config can change the day after the auditors leave.
It covers a sample. PureVPN's 2023 KPMG review looked at seven servers. Mullvad's 2024 Cure53 audit looked at two. Good auditors pick the sample, but it's still a sample.
It has a scope, and the scope has edges. Surfshark's 2026 KPMG review excluded dedicated IP servers, the apps, browser extensions and account and payment systems, as CyberInsider's read of the report shows. That isn't hiding anything. It's just what was in the contract.
In plain English: an audit tells you a provider built its servers not to log and let someone check. It doesn't tell you the provider can never be forced, hacked or tempted into logging later. Think of it like a restaurant hygiene inspection. Worth a lot, and still not a guarantee about tonight's dinner.
Limited vs Reasonable Assurance
Most Big Four VPN reports use ISAE 3000, an international standard for checking things that aren't financial statements. It comes in two strengths.
Limited assurance ends with a negative sentence: "nothing has come to our attention" that suggests the description is wrong. That's the wording in the CyberGhost and PIA reports. Reasonable assurance is a positive opinion that the controls work as described, which takes more testing. ExpressVPN's 2025 KPMG report is a reasonable-assurance report.
There's a second split. A Type 1 report checks that controls were designed and in place on one date. A Type 2 report tests whether they actually operated over a period, usually several months. None of the public reports we read is a Type 2, and none of the 10 vendors describes its report that way. A Type 2 no-logs report covering months of real operation would be a genuine step up.
Four Kinds of Evidence, Ranked
Not every piece of evidence deserves the same weight. This is how we rank them, from strongest to weakest for the specific question "does this VPN keep activity logs?"
Evidence | What it shows | Weakness | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
Server-side no-logs assessment | Servers and processes match the policy on a date | Snapshot, sample, paid by vendor | Proton VPN, Surfshark, NordVPN |
Real-world legal test | No data existed when authorities asked | Usually told by the vendor | Mullvad 2023 search warrant |
Infrastructure or code pentest | Servers are hard to break into | Not designed to hunt for logging | Mullvad 2024, Windscribe 2024 |
App or website audit | The app itself is secure | Says nothing about servers | Many vendors' app audits |
Our take: a recent server-side assessment with a public report is the best paper evidence you'll get. A court case or police raid that came up empty is powerful too, but read who's telling the story. When the only source is the VPN's own blog, it's a claim with good timing, not proof.
Provider Notes: The Catch With Each One
The table gives the facts. These notes give our reading of them, including who each record is weakest for.
Proton VPN
Five consecutive annual Securitum audits (2022 through 2026), each report free to read on Proton's audit page. The 2026 report concludes that Securitum found no evidence the examined servers log browsing activity, DNS queries, destinations, traffic contents or "user-identifiable connection metadata". Proton also says its no-logs policy has held up in more than 400 legal cases, which is its own figure.
Not ideal for: anyone who wants a Big Four name on the report. Securitum is a specialist security firm, not an accounting firm. We think that matters less than the yearly cadence and the open reports.
Surfshark
The newest check here. KPMG assessed Surfshark's controls as of October 30, 2026 and signed the report on November 11. It found that temporary session records on Surfshark's authentication (RADIUS) servers, which can include a user ID, IP address and timestamps, are deleted within 15 minutes of a session ending. Earlier Deloitte reports cover 2023 and 2025.
The catch: "deleted within 15 minutes" is honest, and it also means the data exists for a short while. Dedicated IP servers and the apps were out of scope.
IPVanish
Schellman Compliance completed a no-logs validation on September 25, 2026, IPVanish's third (after Leviathan in April 2022 and Schellman in April 2025). It found no customer activity logs on the examined baseline and sample server, and aggregate abuse statistics kept for up to 24 hours without IP addresses, according to TechNadu's summary.
The catch: in 2016, under its previous owner Highwinds, IPVanish gave US investigators connection details despite a no-logs claim, as TorrentFreak reported from the court filing. The current audits are the answer to that, but the full 2026 report sits behind a customer login, so we couldn't read it ourselves.
NordVPN
Six assessments since 2018, the latest by Deloitte Lithuania with access from November 10 to December 12, 2025, covering standard, Double VPN, Onion Over VPN and obfuscated servers.
Not ideal for: anyone who wants to read the report before buying. It's available only after logging in to a Nord Account. A long track record is good. A report you have to pay to see is a strange way to build trust.
CyberGhost VPN and Private Internet Access
Both have Deloitte Audit Romania reports with the same snapshot date, October 31, 2025, the same standard and the same limited-assurance wording. Both are their third (2022, 2024 and 2025), and both publish the signed PDF for anyone to download.
The catch: limited assurance is the lighter of the two ISAE 3000 levels. That's fine for a policy check, but it's not as strong as the wording ExpressVPN got.
ExpressVPN
KPMG gave reasonable assurance on TrustedServer, ExpressVPN's RAM-only server system, as of February 28, 2025. The report is public once you accept KPMG's terms, and ExpressVPN keeps every audit on one audits page, updated October 20, 2026.
The catch: age. On November 14, 2026, that report is more than 20 months old, and it's a Type 1 snapshot. Strong wording, stale date. We'd want a 2026 report before calling this current.
Windscribe
No standalone no-logs attestation. Its strongest server evidence is a June 2024 Packetlabs review of the FreshScribe server stack: about 80,000 lines of code in 20 repositories plus external and internal penetration testing. Windscribe says the review found "no intentional subversions" of its no-logs policy. It also points to a Greek criminal case against its co-founder that it says was dismissed in April 2025 because it had no user data to hand over.
Not ideal for: buyers who want a formal no-logs opinion signed by an auditor. Windscribe's argument is that court cases are better stress tests than audits. That's a fair point, and it's still mostly told in Windscribe's own words.
Mullvad VPN
Mullvad doesn't commission a formal no-logs attestation. It commissions security audits of its servers instead, most recently Cure53 in June 2024. Cure53 examined one OpenVPN and one WireGuard server, deployed in a staging environment that Mullvad says is configured identically to production, with an explicit focus on anything that could hurt privacy. It reported finding no way to compromise a user's VPN traffic anonymity. Mullvad said it would audit its VPN infrastructure again in 2025. As of November 14, 2026, its audits page lists 2025 and 2026 audits of its web app, payment API and Android app, but no new infrastructure audit.
What Mullvad has that no one else here does: numbered accounts with no email, username or password, and an April 2023 search warrant after which, Mullvad says, police left without customer data. A January 2026 X41 D-Sec code review also notes that its VPN relays hold only a list of allowed keys and don't know which account a key belongs to.
Our take: Mullvad collects so little that there's not much to log. We still want that overdue infrastructure audit.
PureVPN
The newest public report is a KPMG letter dated April 17, 2023, covering fieldwork from February 16 to 22, 2023, on seven servers in six countries. The letter says itself that it wasn't a cybersecurity assessment or a full privacy assessment. PureVPN's December 2025 blog says KPMG made another "always-on" surprise check, but we found no date or report for it.
Not ideal for: anyone who wants recent, readable proof. A 2017 FBI affidavit in a cyberstalking case (published by the US Justice Department) describes PureVPN records linking a customer's accounts to the same VPN IP address and to his home and work IP addresses. The audits since then are meant to show that changed. A three-year-old letter is thin support for that.
Red Flags in a VPN's Audit Claims
Common mistake: reading "audited" on a homepage and stopping there. These signs mean the claim needs a closer look.
No date, or only the press release date, not the period checked.
An app or website audit presented as if it covers logging.
A report you can only read after paying.
The most recent check is older than about 18 months.
A vendor's paraphrase of the auditor's conclusion with no link to the original.
None of these means a provider logs. They mean you're being asked to take more on trust, and the whole point of an audit is to take less.
How to Check Any VPN's Audit in 10 Minutes
You don't need to read 40 pages. This works for any provider, including ones not in our table.
Find the provider's audit or trust page and open the newest no-logs report, not the newest audit of any kind.
Write down the date the check covers. Ignore the announcement date.
Read the scope section and list what was excluded, such as apps, dedicated IPs or payment systems.
Find the conclusion and note whether it says "nothing has come to our attention" or gives a positive opinion.
Check whether the report names a sample size, like seven servers, and whether the auditor chose it.
Search the provider's name with "court" or "logs" to see whether its claim has ever been tested, or broken.
Compare what you found with the user reviews of VPN services on our directory, then decide.
If step 1 takes more than two minutes, that's an answer in itself.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which VPN Has the Most Recent No-Logs Audit?
Surfshark, as of November 14, 2026. KPMG assessed its controls as of October 30, 2026. IPVanish (September 25, 2026) and Proton VPN (2026) follow.
Is an Audited VPN Completely Safe?
No. An audit shows the servers it checked were set up not to log on a given date. It can't rule out a later change, a legal order to start logging or a breach. It lowers the trust you need, not to zero.
Do Free VPNs Get No-Logs Audits?
Some do. Securitum's audit of Proton VPN checks that the no-logs policy applies to every subscription tier, and that includes Proton's free plan. Most unknown free VPN apps publish no audit at all.
How Often Should a VPN Be Audited?
Yearly is a good standard, and Proton, NordVPN and IPVanish have managed it recently. We treat anything older than about 18 months as stale and flag it in this tracker.
The Bottom Line
The best VPN no-logs audit evidence on November 14, 2026 belongs to Proton VPN, for five straight years of public reports, with Surfshark's brand-new KPMG review close behind. NordVPN, IPVanish, CyberGhost and PIA all have checks from the last 13 months, though two keep the report behind a login. ExpressVPN has strong wording on an aging report. Mullvad and Windscribe make a different case, built on minimal data and real-world tests, and PureVPN has the thinnest recent paper trail.
Best by need: Proton VPN if you want proof you can read before paying. Mullvad if you'd rather the provider never knows who you are. Surfshark if you want the freshest Big Four check.
The main warning: an audit is a snapshot, so treat any claim older than about 18 months as unverified until it's renewed.
If you've used any of these services, add your review of Mullvad VPN or whichever one you use. None of the 10 has a published user review on TheUserOpinion yet, and yours would be the first data point next to the paperwork.
- CyberGhostVPN
- ExpressVPN
- IPVanish
- Mullvad
- No-logs audits
- NordVPN
- Privateinternetaccess
- ProtonVPN
- PureVPN
- Surfshark
- VPN
- Windscribe
On TheUserOpinion
Tools mentioned in this guide

CyberGhost VPN
Easy-to-use VPN with audited no-logs privacy
No reviews yet. Be the first.
ExpressVPN
Premium VPN built for speed and simplicity
No reviews yet. Be the first.
IPVanish
VPN with unlimited devices and built-in threat protection
No reviews yet. Be the first.
Mullvad VPN
Privacy-first VPN with anonymous accounts and one flat price
No reviews yet. Be the first.
NordVPN
Fast, private VPN with built-in threat protection
No reviews yet. Be the first.
Private Internet Access
Private, no-logs VPN with wide device support
No reviews yet. Be the first.
Proton VPN
Secure, private VPN from the makers of Proton Mail
No reviews yet. Be the first.
PureVPN
Versatile VPN with dedicated IP and port forwarding
No reviews yet. Be the first.
Surfshark
One VPN account, unlimited devices
No reviews yet. Be the first.
Windscribe
VPN with a generous free plan and unlimited devices
No reviews yet. Be the first.
Written by
Lokesh Kapoor
12 articles on the TheUserOpinion blog.
Used one of these tools?
Honest reviews help the next buyer choose well. Tell others what worked, what didn’t and who it suits.
Keep reading
All articles
Is a VPN Worth It? When You Need One and When You Don't
Is a VPN worth it? Yes on networks you don't trust or when you need another location. No for anonymity, ads or scams. A threat-model table, the hidden costs and which audits to check before you pay.
Lokesh Kapoor
· 11 min read

Online Privacy Tools Explained: VPNs, Proxies and Antidetect
A VPN encrypts a whole device, a proxy changes an IP per app or profile, and an antidetect browser isolates fingerprints. Pick the right privacy layer.
Lokesh Kapoor
· 16 min read
What Is an Antidetect Browser? How It Works, Legitimate Uses and Risks
An antidetect browser lets you run many isolated browser profiles on one computer, each with its own fingerprint, cookies and IP address. Here is how the technology works, who uses it legitimately, where the legal lines are, and the risks to weigh before you choose one.
TheUserOpinion team
· 13 min read